First "Unicorn" FMF

[EastInWest 1,524]

I posted a thread almost two months ago asking for advice on an opportunity to do a "unicorn swap" with the wife and her friend. The responses were cautionary and I think that was warranted, since we were a little blinded by our libidos and maybe biting off more than we could chew involving someone we didn't know.

 

So, instead, we went ahead and did half of it. Maybe still a bad idea, but we felt like it was less of a bad idea.

 

Mrs. E and I talked about it and concluded that it wasn't a good idea because there were too many unknown quantities. Since it had sort of stayed in the storyboard phase with the neighbor, we figured we just wouldn't broach the subject and that if it came up, she'd offer a little white lie that I had just been kidding and that Mrs. E had missed the joke.

 

Move forward a couple of weeks, and sure enough, the neighbor fished around with Mrs. E about it, she explained the situation, and while her friend was cool about it and only slightly disappointed, suggested that it was still something she wanted to try eventually and that there was no need for it to be a reciprocal thing. Surprisingly, Mrs. E told me that she wasn't just open to that, but enthusiastic about it. It sounded less complicated to her, and after talking it out, she had no issues with us trying it other than a couple of physical rules.

 

- She didn't want me cumming inside the neighbor, even with a condom.

- She wanted us all to kiss, but thought it would be too much for them to do oral on each other.

- Not a chance in hell she was going to let there be a video. I tried to renegotiate that one several times.

 

We figured that the worst case "very realistic" scenario was a rumor getting out and that while she'd consider it a bigger scandal than I would, life would go on and she'd just be rumored to be, by far, the most fun wife on the street. Life is short and she wanted to do it, and was hot talking about it in bed. Her getting hot about me with other women during dirty talk is not common but when she does she's really into it and I took it as a signal that she was definitely ready to sign up.

 

There were some girl talk conversations I didn't pry into and we set up a date night for Saturday. Met at a neighborhood pub to get better acquainted and had an early dinner, came back to our place to hang out and have another drink.

 

Long story short, I'm grateful to Eli Lilly and Company for the Cialis assistance with my performance, because despite getting off in the morning, some mutual making out and heavy petting on the couch turned to oral and my first orgasm happened far, far too quickly. Mrs. E was on her knees between my legs and the neighbor resting her head on my lap, while they got acclimated to kissing each other and I fingered the neighbor under her skirt, and I just thought about it all too hard and managed to end up shooting into the air right next to them. They were both startled but we laughed it off and decided to keep fooling around kissing, touching, and licking until I was hard again, then we'd go upstairs.

 

That didn't take too long, and we ended up trying a couple of positions. Mrs. E wanted to cum and wanted me to screw her for a bit with her legs over my shoulders on the edge of the bed, and at first the neighbor hung back sitting on the bed watching, but eventually got into first touching herself, then kissing and touching both of us. I ended up putting on a condom so she could ride me for a while and go at her own pace, and she did need some time to get comfortable enough to put it in but I had fun warming her up with my hands before she sat all the way down on it and got to work. After a few minutes, Mrs. E kissed her a few times and then made out with me and let me suck on her tits while I fingered her, and when I was ready to cum I asked Mrs. E what she wanted, she deferred to the neighbor, and I ended up rolling over with her and taking the condom off to finish on her stomach while she touched herself, which she seemed to really enjoy.

 

We emptied out the bottle of wine we'd opened and I spent the next fifteen minutes or so performing oral on both of them, and I figured we'd end it there but managed to get hard again. Mrs. E and I did 69 for a few minutes, then traded off with the neighbor, then I wanted to screw the neighbor again and let Mrs. E put on a condom so I could take her from behind while they finally got comfortable enough to really make out with each other and play with each other's breasts. Neighbor wanted her hair pulled. Eventually my legs were tired, I couldn't keep going like that, and eventually let Mrs. E jump on top without the condom to try to finish me while the neighbor rested. She did try to sit on my face for a minute but they found it too awkward being right in each other's faces. No chance I was going to climax again, it was unbelievably frustrating, but Mrs. E broke a sweat trying her hardest and came like crazy.

 

We sent her home just after 1:00 am. Made a point of exchanging some normal-sounding pleasantries at the door in case any neighbors overheard. New experience, good experience. Never done FMF without another M hanging around somewhere. Woke up late with a brutal hard-on in the morning and dragged Mrs. E into the shower to finish up what I couldn't the night before. Neighbor texted me while we were in there that she was really glad we invited her over, then they met at the gym as usual and she told Mrs. E in person that she had a lot of fun and was happy she did it. We left it there, although we decided in bed last night after Game of Thrones that if she brings it up we're not going to automatically reject another visit as long as we don't get any weird vibes about it. She's happy we did it, too, and had more fun than she thought she would. She feels like she did something extra-salacious and pushed her boundaries and is very pleased with herself.

 

Moral of the story, if there is one: 10mg of Cialis is an amazing tool for fighting any lingering performance anxiety.

[padoc 1,704]

I should be able to double like this. You had a great night and I salute you!! Wish e had been there.

[EastInWest 1,524]

Maybe I'm just bumping this to humble-brag, but I guess we sized up the situation well enough. Saturday was one of the few sunny days this week, and since I was home, we decided to do some hiking in the state park then go to the gym together afterwards. We got home, decided to cook out, threw some sausages and shrimp on, and then "The Neighbor" jogged by, saw us down the corner, and stopped off to chat.

 

Long story short, we'd planned on making leftovers and had plenty, so invited her to have a bite with us. The conversation was good, touched on her sex life a bit, and between that and the two bottles we'd opened for dinner, we ended up in the bedroom again. Just soft/oral play, before we moved into the bedroom. Eventually, I was screwing Mrs. E from behind and came, and when she got up to clean up, by the time she came back The Neighbor was fast asleep and we just left her there and passed out ourselves. At some point in the night before dawn she woke up, we were all sort of awake, and she apologized profusely for crashing with us - we didn't actually care, although it was all unplanned - before realizing I had a severe hard-on and asked Mrs. E if she could do me before she went home.

 

It was one of those morning erections that's a little insensitive and doesn't go down without a fight, and after she rode it for a while as Mrs. E kissed me, my very helpful wife took the condom off and tried her luck while the Neighbor rubbed herself next to us, before I was finally awake enough and got the idea to put on another condom and jump on top of her missionary. That did the job, and when I was getting warmed up to cum, Mrs. E told me she didn't care if I went ahead. I didn't need to be told twice. Sun was up, birds were singing, nice way to start the day.

 

Neighbor ended up helping with a light breakfast while the weather went south again. We figured they were going to do cardio anyway and it'd look really odd for her to run out of the house in the rain in the same workout gear that early if anyone saw us talking last night, so she just washed up and we hung out for an hour or so before they went together in the car out of the garage.

 

I had to leave town Monday. They had a good talk and clarified that if the Neighbor wants to hang out and we're all feeling it, that's fine, but that she fully understands that it's just for fun, might stop for any reason and isn't an insult, and that we're not going to become some kind of a poly "item". She's getting some kind of a kick out of being the gatekeeper to her friend using my cock and can't quite explain what she's enjoying, but is really having her "this is completely unlike me" fun. This weekend Mrs. E and I are in the city hanging out together and think we're meeting one of the two couples we play with on Saturday. If it works out, we're heading for a new record for play sessions in a month. Life is full of outside stresses at the moment but we're extremely happy about how this is going.

[GoldCoCouple 4,068]

Moral of the story, if there is one: 10mg of Cialis is an amazing tool for fighting any lingering performance anxiety.

 

After everything that happened, THIS is what you took away from it?!!