As you may or may not have noticed, I did not take issue with you personally. Nor did I post anything derogatory about you personally. I only disagreed with the content of your post. If I was too forceful in my disagreement, sorry about that. But not too sorry, because I disagreed strongly. I could have said "I disagree" instead of "this is wrong", and maybe I should have. However, I felt that the response was appropriate for the OP and others reading the thread to see.
Regarding judging, well, this is a board where people give their opinions. It is impossible to do that without using judgment. I gave an opinion on your response, one that addressed things relevant to the topic, without deriding you personally. And I did it in public.
As this is a discussion board, I was discussing the topic of the thread. It's perfectly legitimate, even expected, to discuss earlier responses to a thread as well as the original post. I've been disagreed with in the past and will be again in the future. As long as everything stays polite, which it has so far, I don't see anything wrong with it.
I'll join you in apologizing for the thread jack.