I think it’s expansive to accept there are many sexual preferences, many of which are not appealing to us, that are valid and should not be scorned or criticized. Down the road, some of them could become of interest. Or not.
We had a nice discussion with a couple on a cruise who were into BDSM. We’re not really interested in it, but they told us what a night out is like for them, we told them what a night out is like for us and we all learned new things. Open mindedness to new ideas is a good thing. You don’t have to do it, like it or watch it, but it’s nice to be supportive of other people’s interests and not make them feel weird or aberrant.
I don’t think you’re a hypocrite. You are entitled to your preferences. Not a problem at all.