Normally I don't quote things from this far in the past, but PSULioness I know you're currently active.
I remember in high school there was a classmate of mine "Sarah". Sarah was incredible. Truly incredible. She was beautiful, talented, intelligent... I had the privilege of being a stand partner with her in band for a year. I was dating someone else in band, so I never made any attempt to date her...not that she was 'in my league'. I got to know her pretty well, and she was just an amazing person in general.
One day after school, I was heading to my locker after a club meeting. The school was mostly empty...it was more than an hour since school had let out. As I turned down the hallway for my locker, I could hear Sarah talking with someone in a classroom. I couldn't make out the other person's voice, but I knew Sarah's voice perfectly well. She was complaining to this other person that her breasts were too small. I was dumbfounded. Here was this amazingly perfect young lady whom I know every guy in the school thought was incredible...and she was able to find fault with herself and focus on that fault, to the exclusion of everything else (not that it was a fault in the first place!).
PSULioness, as with many people, you appear to be your own worst critic. The thing is; none of us get to decide if we're attractive or not. All we can do is put forth our best foot. The rest is for other people to decide.